Home / Featured / Former AU quarterback Phil Gargis talks about the 1974 Auburn-Mississippi State game that led to cowbell ban

Former AU quarterback Phil Gargis talks about the 1974 Auburn-Mississippi State game that led to cowbell ban

Screen Shot 2014-10-09 at 9.59.30 AM
They barely lost the game. They almost lost a tradition. Shug, we salute you. (Photo: AU Glomerata)

When the Mississippi State fans rattled their cowbells on Nov. 9, 1974, the person they were trying to rattle the most was Phil Gargis. Gargis, Auburn’s tough-as-nails starting quarterback from 1974-1976 , was under center for the Tigers for their showdown with the Bulldogs in Jackson, ground zero for the cowbell controversy that still rages today.

“You couldn’t hear anything,” Gargis recalls. “It (the cowbells) interfered, no question.”

Sure, the cowbells had always been annoying. That was the point. But the tradition had grown over the past decade because Mississippi State just kept making it easier and easier to participate in. In 1964, ironically the first year of a fairly strict SEC rule forbidding SEC fans from cheering too loudly at football games, MSU’s bookstore began selling custom cowbells with handles welded on for easy ringing.

What do you get when you reduce arm muscle fatigue? More cowbell.

What do you get when it’s a close game (featuring three bench-clearing brawls) against a conference rival your team hasn’t beaten in 10 years? The most cowbell.

MSU's Industrial Education Association welding hand-friendly handles to cowbells in 1974. (Photo: MSU Reveille)
MSU’s Industrial Education Association welding hand-friendly handles to cowbells in 1974. (Photo: MSU Reveille)

“It was definitely a little bit louder than normal because it was a tight game,” Gargis says. “They (MSU) were competitive, they had a pretty good year going.”

Auburn’s great 1974 team finished the season 10-2, beating Texas in the Gator Bowl. The Bulldogs finished the season 9-3 and with a Sun Bowl win over North Carolina.

“I think more people were involved because the cowbells had caught on. Everybody was bringing them. And it was just louder.”

And, according to Gargis, “Coach Jordan was just in one of those moods.”

“He came up to me on the sideline and said ‘do not run the play’. He was trying to get the officials to penalize Mississippi State. Two or three times he asked them to quiet them down,” Gargis says. “I’d look over and he’d shake his head ‘no, no don’t run the play’. They ended up giving us a delay of game.”

Gargis himself asked officials to something about the noise at least eight times. After the game, Shug took referee James Artley to task for not doing his duty.

“All he had to do was walk off 15 yards one time and that would have taken care of things,” said Shug, who actually walked onto the field a couple of times to implore Artley to quiet the crowd. “He knew about it (the bells) beforehand and he still didn’t do anything.”

Phil Gargis being awesome. (Against Missouri, but still.)
Phil Gargis being awesome. (Against Missouri, but still.)

“If we had gotten our butts beat I wouldn’t say anything about this,” Jordan said.

Shug gave Mississippi State credit for “coming back and making one helluva game of it.” But he also blamed the bells for making it as close as it was. That excessive crowd noise rule was being violated with every clang and it was costing Auburn yards, and not just from symbolic protest penalties. Auburn twice jumped off sides. Gargis fumbled on Mississippi State’s six-yard line.

“We had a lot of check offs at the line of scrimmage back then and you just couldn’t hear them,” Gargis says. “It was definitely a factor in the game.”

Mississippi State wound up losing the game, 24-20. They almost lost a tradition in the process.

As he promised in his post-game press conference, Shug wrote SEC Commissioner Boyd McWhorter, who was actually at the game, requesting that cowbells be banned from SEC football games. Several months later, they were.

Many of them wound up in Jordan’s office.

“They came c.o.d.” Jordan said a year later. “I’ve got enough to fill a whole section.”

Related: Guess which school tried to buy 1,000 cowbells from Mississippi State to ring at the 1974 Iron Bowl. (Hint: It wasn’t Auburn.)

If you’d like to help TWER keep on keepin’ on, click here.

More MSU stuff:

* If you can’t deafen’em, blind’em
* Dana Carvey, Kevin Nealon were stoked to watch Auburn beat Mississippi State in 1986 ‘Saturday Night Live’ episode
* Mississippi State fan sues Auburn, SEC over confiscated cowbell; calls rule ‘unconstitutional’
* Shug: ‘The cowbells have no place in college football’
* That time Mississippi State accused Auburn punter Terry Daniel of filling footballs with helium
* Shug: ‘The cowbells have no place in football’

Keep Reading:

* ‘Did you say LSU or LS-PEW?’ Katy Perry uses corn dogs to pick Auburn over LSU in bizarre ESPN GameDay appearance
* Twelve years later, Syracuse sports writer who was ‘Changed Forever’ by Auburn gameday experience reflects on his most popular column ever
* ‘Jeopardy’ contestant whose ‘Cheers’-referencing final response went viral wishes she’d written ‘War Eagle’
* Recent Auburn grad featured in ABC News segment on professional Viners
* Fore Eagle! Auburn fan Zach Manning describes the moment he found Rory McIlroy’s tee shot in his shorts pocket
* Teen who poured her Auburn soul out after wisdom teeth extraction recovering nicely, dishes dirt on Dayton

* What was the probability of an Auburn win before each snap of the 2013 Iron Bowl? Now we know.

Like us on Facebook. Follow us on Twitter. Want to advertise? Spare a dollar?

About Jeremy Henderson

Jeremy Henderson is the editor of The War Eagle Reader and co-host of Rich and Jeremy in the Mornings on Wings 94.3 FM in Auburn. Follow him on Twitter: @wareaglereader / @jerthoughts / @RichandJeremy

Check Also

Bear Bryant lost a recruit to Auburn in the shower

In early 1981, when young sports columnist Paul Finebaum’s story on Bear Bryant “losing his …