Home / Featured / Aubie called as star witness in 1979 trial

Aubie called as star witness in 1979 trial

“I decline to answer on the grounds that I don’t speak.”

Aubie doesn’t speak—we know this. But could he be compelled to testify? Legal eagles have wrestled with the question for years; if they had only emptied their lives of anything better to do than than peruse old issues of the Plainsman, they’d already know the answer: Yes—kind of.

In November 1979, Auburn’s mute mascot was (kind of) called as a witness in the City of Auburn vs. The Old Man, aka Jimmy Smothers. Smothers, an Auburn student, made the up-to-one-year-in-prison mistake of wearing an “old man mask” for Halloween the day before Halloween. He drove down College Street. A cop saw him. The cop arrested him.

The charge? “Concealment of identity.”

Since he wasn’t robbing a bank or burning a cross, Smothers’ attorney Nancy Davis argued that the arrest violated the spirit of the law, which was designed to curb Klan activity back in the day. Do you arrest Kris Kringles come Christmas time? More importantly, do you arrest Aubie come game time?

“Nancy’s theory was if we are going to do that, we might as well arrest the guy who is Aubie and regularly wears a mask,” said Barry Mask, the first Auburn student to officially don Aubie’s sacred stripes. Mask is currently an Alabama state representative from Wetumpka.

The Plainsman’s story on the case (“Aubie plays star witness at trial”), which Davis, who still practices law in Auburn, has framed and hanging in her office, featured a comic drawn by Plainsman cartoonist extraordinaire Bill Hollbrook that suggests Mask was actually in costume on the witness stand. He wasn’t.

“(Davis) thought better of me going into court (as Aubie) because the judge wasn’t much for theatrics,” Mask says.  “She asked me if I had ever been arrested for wearing the Aubie mask. I said ‘no.'”

Mask even testified that once while driving and dressed as Aubie he pulled up next to a police car at a stoplight. The policeman smiled and waved.

“End of case,” Mask says. “The guy walked.”

According The Plainsman, the judge said that while Smothers was “technically guilty,” the arresting officer should have used better judgement under the celebratory circumstances.

In his defense, it could have been the certain “old man mask” that was making the rounds on campus that year. He may have thought he was doing us all a favor.

Related: Is Aubie a Christian?

Keep Reading:

* Cam Newton meets a Mike Vick fan
* Rolling Toomer’s Corner? There’s an app for that
* Auburn creams Tuscaloosa in ‘brainpower index’ rankings
* Shug carves a turkey
* Top American pale ale first brewed in Auburn bathtub

Like us on Facebook. Follow us on Twitter. Want to advertise?

About Jeremy Henderson

Jeremy Henderson is the editor of The War Eagle Reader and co-host of Rich and Jeremy in the Mornings on Wings 94.3 FM in Auburn. Follow him on Twitter: @wareaglereader / @jerthoughts / @RichandJeremy

Check Also

Bear Bryant lost a recruit to Auburn in the shower

In early 1981, when young sports columnist Paul Finebaum’s story on Bear Bryant “losing his …